AdrianHart.net

The Myth of Racist Kids – anti-racist policy and the regulation of school life

Case Studies

Let me know your story.

Do you have direct experience of a child caught up in a 'racist incident' saga?Whether you're a parent, a former pupil, a youth worker or someone that works in a school I'd like to hear from you (click here or comment on the examples below).

The Myth of Racist Kids reports that tens of thousands of officially recorded 'racist incidents' have accumulated since the policy began in 2002.  Local Authorities often reveal that most of these involve "verbal" incidents emanating from primary school 9 to 11 year olds.  Teachers confirm that these incidents are often no more than playgound spats which someone (a child or a member of staff) has felt involved an element of racism.

There are of course genuine instances of sustained and/or targetted bullying (including serious physical assault).  These become included in racist incident statistics.  In the last few years several have been repeatedly quoted in media (click here for 'hammer attack on schoolboy', and here for 'school is first convicted of racist harassment...').  

It is, perhaps, the rarity of these extreme cases that makes them so shocking.  But although I dont want to ignore these cases (and please do report any others to me) they shouldnt distract from how damaging it is that thousands of other "racist incidents" are quite erroneous and simply the result of the very wide dragnet being used.   Advocates of official anti-racism insist that such a claim is simply a myth constructed by 'PC gone mad' news stories in the 'right-wing press'.   They do occassionally admit that statistics inevitably ratchet upwards when a zero-tolerance approach to playground 'racism' is applied.  But this, they argue, is entirely as it should be because of paramount importance is sending out "a powerful message that racism is unacceptable".  The consequences of the policy are never considered and its advocates let off the hook because we keep these stories to ourselves.  Let's change that.



A teacher from Birmingham phones The Jeremy Vine Show ...

The following is transcribed from The Jeremy Vine Show (BBC Radio 2 29/10/09)

JV:  Louise in Birmingham, you’re a teacher?

 I am.

 JV:  So you can tell me how this system works?

 

Some examples:

One headteacher quoted in the report says:

 

"I’ve had to fill out reports for incidents where the child concerned [ie, the victim] hasn’t made any complaint at all, but one of my staff has felt that there’s been an element of racism. We’ve had a few where the children are best friends and so the trick is to try and handle the thing without it breaking up the friendship or instilling the idea of racism when really they haven’t any idea what that is." (p36)

 

He went on to say:

 

"We have to record incidents but they’re rare. A couple of times the County got in touch because we hadn’t reported any incidents for a couple of terms.... You can’t win this one – if you don’t report incidents you’re told you’re not being aware of racism – If you do report it there’ll be someone who decides there’s a major problem in the school".

 

Headteacher Jenny McCutcheon said:

 

"I don’t think its ever been about dealing with targeted bullying. We may have children that don’t like each other!  We had to have a race equality audit because of the number of incidents. So, because we log everything and our procedures are robust we get an audit!"

 

A parent said this:

 

"Last year my 10 year old daughter, mixed race (mother white) and her three friends were accused of racism by the mother of a fifth friend in the group. When the girls were 6, they played a pretend game of one being checkout counter girl and the others being a food item. My daughter wanted to be chocolate, so did a black girl in the group, so my daughter settled for strawberry. THREE years later the black girl mentioned to her mother that she had been called chocolate, which led to a complaint to the school, then an inquiry by the headteacher, a formal notification to my ex-wife and other parents the girls were being investigated for racism, and a lecture to all parents involved about how bad racism is."

 

A parent said this:

 

My 11-year old son was given a one day exclusion last year as a result of a so called 'racist incident' which I thought was absolutely ludicrous given that he had simply used the word 'Paki' to a 'white' class mate when his team had won the quiz in his French lesson!! My son & indeed our whole family have links with ethnic minorities in our own private lives & I can assure you that my son would NEVER deliberately cause upset by actually calling somebody of a different race anything detrimental. The whole thing had been blown out of all proportion as far as we are concerned. I might add that as a family, we have always supported my son's school & their decisions but on this one, we strongly disagreed. 

 

This whole issue has been brought on by ADULTS expecting children to think/behave like adults…God forbid! Children, naturally, are completely oblivious to race/colour or creed but these ridiculous policies are certainly going to draw to their attention children’s differences.  

 


Like this article?
Spread this word to your Friends and Peers

Share |

Adrian Hart Supports the Spiked Campaign 'Open the Borders'
Click on the image below to learn more.

spiked-open-borders

Submit your examples
of 'racist incident' sagas
chat-icon

Click to Play Leave the Kids Alone

Myth of Racist Kids Book Cover
buy-now

 



spiked-open-borders