AdrianHart.net

The Myth of Racist Kids – anti-racist policy and the regulation of school life

Press responses to the Myth of Racist Kids

The Myth of Racist Kids was launched by The Manifesto Club on October 29th 2009.  The press coverage was extensive. Click the links below to read these articles in full:

The Daily Telegraph. October 29th 2009.

The Daily Mail. October 29th 2009.

Ten days earlier The Observer (October 18th 2009) touched on the report in a piece about veteran US diversity trainer Jane Elliot. 

In that same week I also received commissions to write articles for The Daily Mail and The Big Issue (reprinted below).  The Myth of Racist Kids was also criticised in a muddled report in the Birmingham Mail (2nd November 2009).  I comment on this article below. 



30,000 pupils branded as bigots

Posted January 19th 2011

"30,000 pupils branded as bigots: Teachers log 'racist' and 'homophobic' jibes in playground squabbles, even at nursery."

See the Daily Mail article here

Yesterday's front page news story used some data and a few quotes supplied by me.  Heavily sub-edited (I suspect) the piece skipped a few salient points revealed by my research and added a few intriguing points of its own.  But, I think, largely an accurate account, correcting the impression given by a previous Daily Mail headline back in March 2010 – See: ‘Pupils aged 5 on hate register: Teachers must log playground taunts for Government database’.  This referred to Labour government proposals to make the recording and reporting of prejudice-related bullying a legal duty.  It took a careful reading of the March article to realise that whilst pupils of any age may well be named on ‘incident’ forms held in school files, the local authority database “will show incidents and their nature, but not names of pupils” [my emphasis].

 

The Big Issue, November 2009

The Big Issue requested this piece for their monthly column 'If I was King for a Day'

"There’s a lot of talk about race and racism.  It might be the BNP or Islamophobia or an offensive word uttered on Strictly… I wonder if all this talk misleads us into thinking society is as racist as it ever was.  Maybe in 2009 it’s the rarity of racial tensions and violence that make it shocking to us?

Growing up in the 1970s, I remember how everyday and acceptable racism was.  In my provincial comprehensive I was the nearest thing anyone had (because of my dark skin) to insult with “paki” – even a few of my teachers joined in.

But today its not just that life has improved for Britain’s ethnic minorities – there’s something else going on – something amazing.  My work takes me into a lot of primary schools and you can see it.  Almost 20% of British children under 16 belong to an ethnic minority.  Nearly 10% live in a family that has multiple, white, black or Asian heritage.  In other words the dubious concept of ‘race’ is falling apart at a gathering pace.  The extent to which playgrounds and classrooms have become crucibles for kids to transcend race and carry that forward is something to celebrate.  Its like a hot-air balloon set to rise up above all our adult centred race-talk.  

But there’s a problem. Since 2002, the government has  required schools to officially report anything perceived to be a “racist incident”.  The dragnet has accumulated tens of thousands of incidents so far.  Typical of the incidents submitted to local authorities are kids insulting each other with phrases like ‘chocolate bar’ – in east London its often Bangladeshi kids using the term Kalabander to insult other Bangladeshi kids (it means ‘black monkey’). 

The statistics are frequently used to conjur the idea that kids need educating about their racism and to learn respect for ‘racial identity’.

King for a day?  For a start, I’d allow schools the freedom to throw counter-productive anti-racism out of the basket and let the balloon rise.  In playgrounds, kids are doing anti-racism all by themselves." 

 

Muddled reporting

The Birmingham Mail commented on The Myth of Racist Kids on Nov 2nd 2009 with a headline that read "Rise in racist incidents in Birmingham schools is denied by senior education officer".   The muddle here is similar to Channels 4s report from 2007 whereby the rise in the reporting of incidents is conflated with a rise in racism itself.  Faced with my reports claim that the number of recorded racist incidents in schools had almost doubled since 2003 the Birmingham official could only assert that actual racism hadn't risen (although monitoring had "improved").

 

 


Like this article?
Spread this word to your Friends and Peers

Share |

Adrian Hart Supports the Spiked Campaign 'Open the Borders'
Click on the image below to learn more.

spiked-open-borders

Submit your examples
of 'racist incident' sagas
chat-icon

Click to Play Leave the Kids Alone

Myth of Racist Kids Book Cover
buy-now

 



spiked-open-borders